gradeornot

Is this card worth grading?

Grading costs real money and months of waiting, and most cards come back worth less than the fee. Answer a few questions about the card in your hand and this works out the grade you need to break even, what the submission actually costs once shipping and selling fees are in, and your odds of clearing it.

1Which card

2What shape is it in

Centering
Corners
Edges
Surface
Anything on this list

3How you would send it

Got a real sold comp

One real sold price beats every estimate in this app. Paste one if you have it.

Do not send it

Estimates only
Edge vs selling it raw
-$78.58
Break even
None
Odds
0%
Cost per card
$83.35
Where this card is likely to gradeNo grade on the scale pays for the submission.
Show these numbers as a table
GradeChanceOutcome
107.2%Loses money
942.7%Loses money
842.7%Loses money
77.2%Loses money
Show every grade and where its price came from
Price at each grade, and where each price came from
GradeWorthSource
10$96Our estimate
9$36.8Our estimate
8$27.2Our estimate
7$22.4Our estimate
6$19.2Our estimate
5$17.6Our estimate
4$14.4Our estimate
3$11.2Our estimate
2$9.6Our estimate
1$9.6Our estimate

Why

  • No grade on the scale pays for the submission on this card. Even a perfect 10 comes back worth less than the fees you paid to get it.
  • All in cost is $83.35 per card at a batch of 20, against a PSA Regular sticker price of $79.99. Shipping and supplies are the rest.
  • Selling it raw today nets about $19.97 after selling costs. Grading it nets about -$58.61 on average, a difference of -$78.58.
  • Graded prices here are era based estimates, not sold comps. Paste one real sold price for the grade you care about and this answer gets far sharper.
  • You wait roughly 45 days for the result, and the card is out of your hands the whole time.
  • Centering was eyeballed, so the estimate carries more spread than it needs to.
Nets if graded
-$58.61
Nets if sold raw
$19.97

How it gets to an answer

Step 1

Pick the card

Search for it, or type the raw market price yourself. The year matters more than people expect: a 1999 holo and a 2024 holo of the same raw price behave completely differently once they are in a slab.

Step 2

Measure the centering

Centering is the one thing a phone can judge objectively, so the app measures it from a photo instead of asking you to eyeball it. Eyeballed answers are shaded down, because people are kind to their own cards.

Step 3

Read the edge

The answer is not whether a slab is worth more than a raw card, which is almost always yes and almost always misleading. It is whether the gain covers the fee, the postage, the selling costs and the wait.

The longer version covers the grade model, where the prices come from, and what the app refuses to claim.

It tells you when it is guessing

Every graded price carries where it came from: a sold price you entered, a market data provider, or the app's own era based estimate. The verdict shows which, at every grade, and names the one the decision actually turns on.

When the whole curve is estimated, the app will not say send unless the edge is large enough to survive the estimate being wrong. A coin flip dressed up as advice is worse than no advice, and this is the exact mistake the product exists to prevent.